my heart just really drowned in a pool of sadness when i heard about the stampede incident. i really want to write about it, despite my lack of time. i have extreme guilt soaped all over my entire being while i was watching the coverage of the supposed first year anniversary celebration of wowowee turned tragedy – my life with all of its few blessings (which i often take for granted) compared to the victims who most likely used up all their savings or perhaps borrowed some money to buy one-way tickets to manila hoping to bring home some cash. unfortunately, now they have no money to fend for themselves and for the 79, no more lives to live, leaving their families all the more poorer.
i read a relevant article about the world’s deadliest stampedes in the past 2 decades. most of the reasons for these stampedes were religious fanaticism and sports. none about poverty-compelled mass hysteria.

there are just so many angles from which to speak about it. there were talks about security issues; undying rating wars – noontime shows preying on the desperate with their glitzy promises of “helping the poor” and “making them happy”; and there was the poverty issue. it’s alarming to see that a large number of people are placing their hopes for a better future on the refulgent promises of their celebrity idols.it got me thinking… how poor are we to run like animals to get a chance to have a little cash, desperate needs, calls for desperate measures… is that how pathetic we Filipinos are???

these are just some of the musings i ended up with. we really cannot point fingers at anybody right now – whose fault is it anyway?! i really don’t know. maybe it’s ABS CBN’s fault – failure to foresee all these; maybe it’s the people’s fault – they were the one pushing and shoving their way into the stadium anyway… i don’t know, maybe it’s everyone’s fault: the media, the government, the society, the generation before us, and the generation before that. we all created this situation, putting noontime shows on the pedestal because “they help the poor.” then again, is this how you help the poor? take advantage of their poverty; with the underlying goal of becoming the number one most watched noontime show. however, giving the kapamilya network the benefit of the doubt, they really help a lot of people everyday. giving as much as one thousand bucks per contestant. and concept-wise it’s touching to see the balikbayan’s generosity towards the less fortunate.
i just don’t know how to react, what to feel, whom to blame… it’s just sad. I hope that we Filipinos learned from this incident. Let us all pray for solace for those who are injured and strength for the families of those who have passed.
—————————————————————————-
this is by far my favorite article from the papers, nobody could have said it better:
There’s The Rub : Tragedy
First posted 11:42pm (Mla time) Feb 05, 2006
By Conrado de Quiros
Inquirer
click here for the original link of this article
Editor’s Note: Published on page A14 of the February 6, 2006 issue of the Philippine Daily Inquirer
IT MIGHT HAVE BEEN A SCENE STRAIGHT from a war, a killer earthquake, or a landslide in a far-flung corner of the country. Men and women wailing and sending their lamentations to the heavens. The stench of death hovering over litter and debris. The casualty rate staggeringly high, and counting. But it wasn’t a war or an earthquake or a landslide. And it wasn’t in a place God forgot and was remembered by media only because of the pain and anguish that now emanated from it.
It was the disaster at Ultra last Saturday. Like many Filipinos, I woke up with a jolt last Saturday morning from TV sets blaring in the neighborhood, delivering the shocking news that 60 people-at the time I heard it; the number would climb steadily as the hours went by-had died from a stampede. A throng had jostled and pushed, eventually sparking a riot that claimed the lives of that many people, most of them women and children. People would later tearfully recount how their children were torn off from their grasp by the sheer force of the melee. I will not go into the more gruesome details as TV was full of them last Saturday. Many issued calls to their loved ones, promising to wait at the gate for them till they came. Your mind reeled at the thought they might be addressing kids that would never come back to them. That they would never see again.
Most of those who had gone there and who now issued those tearful calls had one thing in common. They were poor. Their faces bore years of toil and frustration, arduous work and tenuous hope. They came from as far as Cavite and Calamba, Bulacan and Pampanga. Some came farther, from the Visayas. All had gone there in anticipation of coming home with some cash. The show had been showering its audience with money, and money was the one thing they needed badly. And it was the show’s anniversary, promising boundless bounties for those who would be lucky enough to get them. Who knows? Maybe they would be lucky that day.
They were not. You did not know who was the more unlucky, those who were trodden underfoot or those who lived to see the lifeless bodies of their children.
I have an idea of the horror of the event. In 2000, my boy, who was 12 years old at the time, and I went to Naga to attend the centennial celebrations of the Peñafrancia fiesta. It drew a record attendance of devotees, the entire centro packed with sweaty bodies. At one point, a crowd surged toward us as we were walking on a sidewalk, and it was all I could do to shield my son from the crush of bodies that fell upon us. I could feel a huge force pressing on my back as I pushed back, my hands to the wall. Terror and panic welled up inside me and I was monumentally thankful it lasted for only a few minutes. That image flashed in my brain last Saturday. I multiplied what I had felt a thousand times, and I imagined that was how the victims must have felt.
I’ve seen tragedies like this before but none so telling about the state of the nation or the plight of the Filipino today than this one. I guess the one that comes closest to the sense of shock Metro Manilans felt was the fire at the Ozone Disco more than a decade ago. It shared in the same spirit of something joyous that turned into bitter tragedy. I do not now recall how many scores of people died there. I do recall that the disco was full of kids who had gone there to celebrate their graduation. A faulty wiring sent sparks flying and soon the place was engulfed in fire. Lacking any safety measures, the place became a death trap. Scores died from the smoke, from being trampled upon, and from being burned to death.
Last Saturday’s disaster shares another thing with the Ozone Disco fire, which is that it was completely preventable. The people responsible for the show cannot escape blame for what has happened. True, the crowd was to blame too for shoving and pushing. True, the crowd was to blame too for preventing the ambulances from reaching the victims on time. True, the crowd was to blame too for lacking discipline and sobriety. But you know that crowds in this country are like that. You know a crowd that enormous and the prospect of gain for the few that are lucky enough to get in are a combustible mix. And you just leave things well enough alone? And you do not take measures to ensure some order in the chaos, some method in the madness? And you just say at the end of the day we did not want this to happen, we grieve with the victims’ kin?
But as many Filipinos know by now-courtesy of the text messages that flew thick and fast after the event-the real culprit in this disaster is poverty. A friend of mine put it this way, "Grabe pare, the only things that are keeping the poor going these days are luck and alms." That sounds even more plaintive in Tagalog. Another said the tragedy showed the true face of the economy. It is not 51 to 1, which is the conversion rate of the peso, it is 74 to 1, the conversion rate of lives to survival.
What can I say? I agree completely. What differentiates the tragedy last Saturday with the ones that came before it is that people went there out of dire straits, out of desperation, out of need to make some money. And they pushed and shoved and trampled with a ferocity reserved only for their life-and-death struggles. Kapit sa patalim. Surviving by the skin of your teeth. At least the victims of the collapse of the Colgante Bridge in Naga were there to show religious devotion to their Ina. At least the fans that were stampeded to death at Amoranto were there to show devotion to their rock gods. The children, women and men who were crushed to death at Ultra were there to cling to life. They were there trusting in God, luck and gratuity.
That is the greatest tragedy of all.